trigger and PID no change, only by set

[Guest]

Originally posted by: <email address deleted>

Hi,

I'm using a cron job and with a script to simualte and oregon device
to set the PID

The script contains

#!/bin/sh
datum=$(date +%Y-%m-%d)
tijd=$(date +%H:%M:%S)
temp=$(/usr/bin/fhem.pl localhost:7072 "l Slaapkamertempje" | grep T:
| cut -d " " -f11)
/usr/bin/fhem.pl localhost:7072 'trigger tempslaap ; {\
  $defs{tempslaap}{STATE}="T: '$temp'  H: 0";;\
  $defs{tempslaap}{READINGS}{temperature}{VAL}="'$temp'";;\
  $defs{tempslaap}{READINGS}{temperature}{TIME}="'$datum' '$tijd'"}'

While running the script it works

fhem> l tempslaap
Internals:
   CODE       THGR228N_00
   DEF        THGR228N_00
   IODev      RFXCOM
   NAME       tempslaap
   NR         23
   STATE      T: 16.8  H: 0
   TYPE       OREGON
   Readings:
     2011-10-19 19:40:02   temperature     16.8
Attributes:
   fm_order   22

When settig the PID with an desired temp it works

fhem> set thermostaat_slaapkamer desired 18
fhem> l thermostaat_slaapkamer
Internals:
   DEF        tempslaap:temperature:([\d\.]*) thermostaat_slaap
   NAME       thermostaat_slaapkamer
   NR         45
   STATE      16.8 (delta 1.2)
   TYPE       PID
   actor      thermostaat_slaap
   command    valve
   dFactor    5.88235294117647
   iFactor    3.05882352941176
   pFactor    25.4901960784314
   reading    temperature
   regexp     ([\d\.]*)
   satMax     100
   satMin     0
   sensor     tempslaap
   Readings:
     2011-10-19 19:45:54   actuation       37.9294117647059
     2011-10-19 19:45:54   delta           1.2
     2011-10-19 19:45:54   desired         18
     2011-10-19 19:45:54   integrator      7.34117647058823
Attributes:
   room       Slaapkamer


But the script runs every 5 minutes, but the PID doesn't update. the
tempslaap went to 16.9 but not the state of the pid. Is this beacuse
trigger is not enough???

If I do set thermostaat_slaapkamer desired 18

it reads then tempslaap again.

any ideoa howto solve this?

regards Richard

--
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to
fhem-users+unsubscribe@googlegroups.com

[rudolfkoenig]

                                                   

> /usr/bin/fhem.pl localhost:7072 'trigger tempslaap ; {\
>   $defs{tempslaap}{STATE}="T: '$temp'  H: 0";;\
>   $defs{tempslaap}{READINGS}{temperature}{VAL}="'$temp'";;\
>   $defs{tempslaap}{READINGS}{temperature}{TIME}="'$datum' '$tijd'"}'

This is most certainly not what you want. As you are generating an event for
the devices tempslaap WITHOUT any arguments, the PID is not reacting to it.
Setting some internal fhem variables AFTER the trigger is quite useless.

I propose:
  trigger tempslaap:$temp;; setstate tempslaap T: $temp  H: 0

The second command is only cosmetic, in case you'd like to see the current value
in tempslaap too and not only in the PID.

--
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to
fhem-users+unsubscribe@googlegroups.com

[Guest]

Originally posted by: <email address deleted>

Rudolf,

You mean like this



#!/bin/sh
datum=$(date +%Y-%m-%d)
tijd=$(date +%H:%M:%S)
temp=$(/usr/bin/fhem.pl localhost:7072 "l Slaapkamertempje" | grep T:
| cut -d " " -f11)
/usr/bin/fhem.pl localhost:7072 'trigger tempslaap:'$temp';; setstate
tempslaap T: '$temp'  H: 0'

i get error

Please define tempslaap:17.2; first


And I have this in the config in fhem.cfg

define tempslaap OREGON THGT228N_00

define thermostaat_slaapkamer PID tempslaap:temperature:([\d\.]*)
thermostaat_slaap


what goes wrong???



On Oct 20, 8:45 am, Rudolf Koenig wrote:
> > /usr/bin/fhem.pl localhost:7072 'trigger tempslaap ; {\
> >   $defs{tempslaap}{STATE}="T: '$temp'  H: 0";;\
> >   $defs{tempslaap}{READINGS}{temperature}{VAL}="'$temp'";;\
> >   $defs{tempslaap}{READINGS}{temperature}{TIME}="'$datum' '$tijd'"}'
>
> This is most certainly not what you want. As you are generating an event for
> the devices tempslaap WITHOUT any arguments, the PID is not reacting to it.
> Setting some internal fhem variables AFTER the trigger is quite useless.
>
> I propose:
>   trigger tempslaap:$temp;; setstate tempslaap T: $temp  H: 0
>
> The second command is only cosmetic, in case you'd like to see the current value
> in tempslaap too and not only in the PID.

--
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to
fhem-users+unsubscribe@googlegroups.com

[rudolfkoenig]

                                                   

> what goes wrong???

Please read http://fhem.de/commandref.html#trigger carefully:

  trigger

->
  /usr/bin/fhem.pl localhost:7072 "trigger tempslaap $temp"

--
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to
fhem-users+unsubscribe@googlegroups.com

[Guest]

Originally posted by: <email address deleted>

Rudolf

Ok I get it but PID doesn't respond also, the pid stays wrong?



fhem> trigger tempslaap 17
fhem> l tempslaap
Internals:
   CODE       THGT228N_00
   DEF        THGT228N_00
   IODev      RFXCOM
   NAME       tempslaap
   NR         23
   STATE      T: 17
   TIME       2011-10-20 17:00:02
   TYPE       OREGON
   Readings:
     2011-10-20 17:00:02   temperature     17.2
Attributes:
   fm_order   22

fhem> l thermostaat_slaapkamer
Internals:
   DEF        tempslaap:temperature:([\d\.]*) thermostaat_slaap
   NAME       thermostaat_slaapkamer
   NR         46
   STATE      17.4 (delta -1.4)
   TYPE       PID
   actor      thermostaat_slaap
   command    valve
   dFactor    5.88235294117647
   iFactor    3.05882352941176
   pFactor    25.4901960784314
   reading    temperature
   regexp     ([\d\.]*)
   satMax     100
   satMin     0
   sensor     tempslaap
   Readings:
     2011-10-19 22:37:20   actuation       0
     2011-10-19 22:37:20   delta           -1.4
     2011-10-19 22:37:20   desired         16
     2011-10-19 22:37:20   integrator      0
Attributes:
   room       Slaapkamer





On Oct 20, 5:37 pm, Rudolf Koenig wrote:
> > what goes wrong???
>
> Please readhttp://fhem.de/commandref.html#triggercarefully:
>
>   trigger
>
> ->
>   /usr/bin/fhem.pl localhost:7072 "trigger tempslaap $temp"

--
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to
fhem-users+unsubscribe@googlegroups.com

[Guest]

Originally posted by: <email address deleted>

Rudolf

I got the issue

trigger tempslaap temperature 17

than it works.

On Oct 20, 7:18 pm, kroonen wrote:
> Rudolf
>
> Ok I get it but PID doesn't respond also, the pid stays wrong?
>
> fhem> trigger tempslaap 17
> fhem> l tempslaap
> Internals:
>    CODE       THGT228N_00
>    DEF        THGT228N_00
>    IODev      RFXCOM
>    NAME       tempslaap
>    NR         23
>    STATE      T: 17
>    TIME       2011-10-20 17:00:02
>    TYPE       OREGON
>    Readings:
>      2011-10-20 17:00:02   temperature     17.2
> Attributes:
>    fm_order   22
>
> fhem> l thermostaat_slaapkamer
> Internals:
>    DEF        tempslaap:temperature:([\d\.]*) thermostaat_slaap
>    NAME       thermostaat_slaapkamer
>    NR         46
>    STATE      17.4 (delta -1.4)
>    TYPE       PID
>    actor      thermostaat_slaap
>    command    valve
>    dFactor    5.88235294117647
>    iFactor    3.05882352941176
>    pFactor    25.4901960784314
>    reading    temperature
>    regexp     ([\d\.]*)
>    satMax     100
>    satMin     0
>    sensor     tempslaap
>    Readings:
>      2011-10-19 22:37:20   actuation       0
>      2011-10-19 22:37:20   delta           -1.4
>      2011-10-19 22:37:20   desired         16
>      2011-10-19 22:37:20   integrator      0
> Attributes:
>    room       Slaapkamer
>
> On Oct 20, 5:37 pm, Rudolf Koenig wrote:
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
> > > what goes wrong???
>
> > Please readhttp://fhem.de/commandref.html#triggercarefully:
>
> >   trigger
>
> > ->
> >   /usr/bin/fhem.pl localhost:7072 "trigger tempslaap $temp"

--
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to
fhem-users+unsubscribe@googlegroups.com